Our Featured Products

As our name implies, cheese takes center stage in our store. Our collection of 120 cheeses features local varieties produced by small Amish farms and local Holmes County cheese makers, as well as imported fanciful cheeses hailing from Scotland, Ireland, Finland, Holland and other countries.

Complementing our dairy products are freshly smoked and locally produced meats that are big on flavor. Boasting “Ohio ingredients, Ohio made,” other favorites include dips, spreads, jams, syrups, snacks, baking mixes, pickles and condiments, which are made in our own kitchen or by local farmers.

Homemade in our store every week, our Sweeties chocolates and fudge are offered in heavenly varieties that are sure to delight any chocolate lover! Even the caramel, peanut butter and maple creams used inside the candies are homemade with Grandma’s secret recipes.

Cheeses
View All

Cheeses

Dips & Spreads
View All

Dips & Spreads

Pickles & Sauces
View All

Pickles & Sauces

Preserves & Syrups
View All

Preserves & Syrups

Snacks
View All

Snacks

Drinks & Baking Mixes
View All

Drinks & Baking Mixes

Baking
View All

Baking

Candies & Chocolates
View All

Candies & Chocolates

View All

Seasonal